Human-led interviews
Prefer to meet candidates yourself from the start? Human-led mode keeps you in the conversation while HireMike helps with applications, optional CV screening, bookings and offers.
Choosing human-led mode
On the job’s Settings page, open AI Interview and, under Interviews, pick "I'll interview candidates myself" — "Candidates who pass CV screening go straight to your board. You book and run every interview. No AI interview charges."
What changes on the Settings page:
- The Interview Questions section keeps its heading but loses the editor. It reads "Interview questions aren't needed — you'll run interviews yourself." Any questions you wrote are kept, and come back if you switch to AI. Try this interview goes with the editor — there is no AI interview to try.
- The Interview Type section (scheduling, Allow instant start) disappears — there's no AI interview to schedule.
- Hold invitations for review disappears. A hold delays an AI interview invitation, and a human-led job sends none — your board is the review step. Passing candidates reach your board straight away.
- Publishing does not require interview questions. Scoring criteria are required only if AI CV screening stays on.
- Knockout screening still applies. Knockout questions and their required answers must pass the same essential-requirement review before saving or publishing; you can also use none. This is separate from the retained AI interview questions.
- The header chip reads Human-led.
Human booking notice
Under Job settings → AI Interview → Booking notice, use the Company human notice or set a notice for this job. Choose Set a human notice period for this job, enter a whole number from 0 to 168 hours, and save. 0 offers the next free slot within your availability. Restore Use account default to inherit again. This affects offered human slots, candidate booking and rescheduling; existing bookings keep their times. AI booking notice remains separate.
The human-led flow
- Candidates apply through the same knockout questions and CV upload. With AI CV screening on, HireMike scores their CV and applies the 2-hour rejection window. The confirmation email uses Application received (human-led interviews) and says you will contact them directly.
- Passing candidates skip the AI interview entirely. With AI CV screening off, completed applications go straight to New, without a CV score or screening charge. They receive "You've been shortlisted — {job title}" ("{company} will contact you directly to arrange an interview" — no interview link), and land on your board as New.
- You review the CV and any screening results on the CV tab. Decide who to interview.
- You book interviews from each candidate's profile with Book interview — either "Candidate chooses" (self-booking against your weekly availability) or "I'll set a time" (details). Booked candidates sit in the Interview column; confirmations and 24h/1h reminders go out automatically.
- After each conversation, hit Mark completed on the booking — the candidate moves to Interviewed — and record your thoughts in their private notes or the booking's internal note.
- Offers and hiring work exactly as in AI mode: Offers & hiring.
You lead the conversation and record your own notes, with no AI interview charge. Everything else (rejection flows, daily summaries) behaves identically. Re-invite works here too, but a re-invited candidate gets the shortlisted email and returns to your board — no AI interview link (details). The candidate's status page reflects the human flow: after passing CV screening they see Application under review ("the hiring team will contact you by email") rather than any claim an interview has happened, and it moves to Interview booked once you book one.
Note: In human-led mode a candidate can't reach an AI interview, even with an old link. An old interview link answers "This interview is now being arranged directly by the employer — they'll be in touch to set up a time. Check your status page for updates." An old booking link answers "Nothing to schedule right now". They can follow your updates instead, so it helps to let them know the next step.
Switching modes on a published job
You can change a live job's mode at any time from AI Interview on its Settings page. Because real candidates may be mid-flight, clicking the other card first shows an impact summary counting exactly who's affected, and nothing happens until you confirm.
Switching AI → human-led
The confirmation panel tells you, with live counts:
- Candidates awaiting their AI interview — their interview/booking links stop working immediately and they appear on your board as New, ready for you to arrange interviews. The count includes anyone held at Awaiting your review; they move across now instead of waiting out the hold.
- Booked AI interviews — the bookings and their reminder emails are cancelled; those candidates also land on the board as New.
- AI interviews happening right now — allowed to finish normally, and billed as usual; their assessments arrive as normal.
- Candidates who already completed their AI interview are untouched.
A checkbox — "Email affected candidates…" (ticked by default) — sends everyone whose link changed an "Update on your interview — {job title}" email so each candidate knows to expect the next step from you.
Switching human-led → AI
The panel warns that future screening passers will now receive AI interview invitations, which are charged per completed interview, and offers:
- "Send those N candidates an AI interview invitation now" (ticked by default) — candidates already sitting on your board in New or Reviewed with no interview booked get fresh AI interview invitations immediately. They leave your board while they interview, and return as New when the interview finishes. "Candidates with an interview already booked or completed are never re-invited" — anyone you're actively interviewing stays exactly where they are.
The job needs one to five reviewed interview questions, each no longer than 400 characters, and at least one scoring criterion before it can switch to AI mode. Your saved AI questions stay available if you choose to use them later. Switching to AI requires the questions to pass review against the saved job details. Add interview questions in AI Interview and scoring criteria in CV Screening first. The scoring criteria guide the interview assessment, even when AI CV screening is off.
Criteria and switching modes
If AI screens CVs, use criteria that a CV can support, even when you run interviews yourself. If you turn screening off, a human-led job needs no criteria; any you add still receive general writing checks.
Before switching to AI interviews, save your job wording and criteria so HireMike can check the version you want to use. If a check needs attention, CV Screening guides you to the relevant field. Your edits remain available, and earlier results stay as they were.
Human booking notice also applies to follow-up interviews on AI jobs, independently of the AI booking notice.
Rules and edge cases
- Mode switching on a published job always goes through the confirmation panel; on a draft it's just a setting; a closed job can't switch.
- After confirming you'll get a summary toast of what happened (candidates moved, bookings cancelled, invitations sent, emails sent).
- If a teammate switched the job moments before you, you'll see "changed elsewhere — refresh" rather than a double-switch.
- Billing: switching never creates surprise charges — the only interview charges in a switch are AI interviews already in progress that complete.
- If your account is suspended, top up before switching with Send those N candidates an AI interview invitation now selected — the panel says "Your account has been suspended — top up to restore access." Top up, or untick the box and switch without inviting anyone.
Choosing between the modes
| Consider | AI mode | Human-led |
|---|---|---|
| Your time per candidate | Minutes (review the assessment) | An interview slot each |
| Speed to first signal | Same-day possible (instant start) | Limited by your diary |
| Consistency | Shared questions and criteria, with follow-up questions based on answers | You choose the questions and record your notes |
| Cost | Completed AI interviews, plus CV screening when enabled | CV screening only when enabled |
| Personal touch | After the AI round | From the first conversation |
A common pattern: run AI mode to cut a large field down to a strong shortlist, interview finalists yourself via Book interview (which works in both modes), and reserve human-led for senior or sensitive roles where the first contact should be personal.
Related: Publishing & job settings · Managing candidates · Calendar & availability