Skip to content
Hire Mike

Managing candidates

Keep your hiring moving, one clear next step at a time. From a candidate’s profile, you can build your shortlist, arrange a conversation, send an offer or close the loop with a thoughtful update.

All of these live in the action bar at the top of a candidate's profile. Which buttons you see depends on their current stage:

Stage Available actions
New ☆ Shortlist · Mark reviewed · Book interview · Send offer · Reject
Reviewed ☆ Shortlist · Book interview · Send offer · Reject
Interview (booked) ☆ Shortlist · Send offer · Reject (booking actions are on the booking itself)
Interviewed ☆ Shortlist · Book interview (another round) · Send offer · Reject
Offer Sent ☆ Shortlist · Reject · the offer actions — see Offers & hiring
Hired / Rejected No further actions (re-invite is available from the Rejected view)

Candidates still in the automated stages (applied/screening/invited) aren't on the board yet, but their profile is not read-only. ☆ Shortlist and Reject are always there. Send offer appears after the CV check or when a completed application waits for manual CV review. You can offer without an interview. If you haven't reviewed or interviewed them, HireMike asks you to confirm first.

Resend invitation is not in the action bar. It sits in the Waiting for candidate to complete AI interview panel on the same profile. You can also book their AI interview yourself — see Booking for them.

Candidates awaiting your CV review

When the job holds invitations for review, open a candidate from Awaiting your review and read their CV tab. Use Send now on the profile to release their invitation, or Reject to decline them. Use Previous and Next to review the queue without returning to the list. The selected tab stays open where available.

The queue also supports several candidates at once. Select their rows, then choose Invite or Reject. Bulk rejection delays the emails for 48 hours. Check the result for any candidates whose action failed. See CV screening for review deadlines and automatic decisions.

When an email doesn't reach them — "Can't reach"

A missed email does not have to mean a missed opportunity. If an address contains a typo or a mailbox is no longer available, HireMike helps you spot the problem and send the candidate’s update again.

HireMike tracks delivery of candidate emails. When a mail server refuses one permanently, three things happen:

  • The candidate's card gets a red Can't reach badge on the board.
  • The line in their History turns red and says what went wrong — for example, "HireMike could not deliver the interview invitation email — the address does not exist."
  • If the email was one the candidate has to act on — an invitation, a booking link, an offer — the deadline stops. They are not rejected for missing a message they never received. The History says so too: "HireMike stopped the deadline for the candidate."

Fixing the address

Open the candidate, go to the History tab, and press Fix address on the red line. Type the correct address and press Save and send again.

HireMike then:

  1. Checks the new address the same way it checks an address on the apply form.
  2. Clears the Can't reach badge.
  3. Sends the email that bounced again.
  4. If the bounce stopped a deadline, starts it again from now — the candidate gets their full window. A candidate who had no deadline (for example, on a human-led job) still has none.

Two things to know:

  • Update the address before resending. Once you correct it, HireMike can send the message again.
  • Keep each candidate’s history separate. Choose an address that is not already used by another candidate. If both records belong to the same person, contact support for help.

The other things you can see

The line says What it means What to do
HireMike delivered the … email It arrived. Nothing.
The … email did not arrive yet (amber) The mail server is trying again. This is temporary. Wait. It becomes delivered or bounced on its own.
HireMike could not deliver the … email (red) The mailbox refused it. Fix the address.
The candidate marked the … email as unwanted mail They pressed the spam button. Nothing. HireMike stops emailing them.
HireMike could not send the … email (amber) Different. Our own send failed, not the candidate's mailbox. HireMike tries again automatically. Nothing.

A candidate whose email arrived normally shows no extra colour at all — that is the usual case.

Questions the candidate asked

If a candidate asked the AI interviewer something it couldn't answer and agreed to have it passed on, you'll have received an email — "Interview question from {candidate} — {job title}" — and the question is kept on their profile under Questions from the candidate, shown next to the transcript on the Interview tab. Older links to a separate Transcript tab open Interview. Every one is also in the History timeline with its timestamp.

Reply to the candidate directly by email; HireMike doesn't carry the answer back to them. The question is kept alongside the interview, and you can reply while the rest of your hiring process continues as usual. See The AI interview. A question about an offer works the other way: it lands on your Questions page, where you answer it and HireMike emails the reply. See Answering candidate questions.

Shortlisting

The ☆ Shortlist toggle is a bookmark. It puts a ★ Shortlisted badge on the candidate's card, and a star beside their name in Compare. It does nothing else — no emails, no stage change. Use the star to spot your favourites as you review the board. There is not currently a separate shortlist filter.

Mark reviewed

On a New candidate, Mark reviewed moves them to the Reviewed column. It’s a simple way to keep track of who you’ve considered, without sending an email. Your New column then stays focused on people you haven’t reviewed yet.

Booking a follow-up interview

Book interview opens a modal with two paths:

"Candidate chooses"

Sends the candidate a self-booking link driven by your weekly hours (Calendar → Availability) — or by the chosen meeting type's own weekly availability, where it has one — minus times you already have interviews booked. You pick the format — video / phone / in person — with the meeting link or location, and the duration; the candidate receives a booking invitation and picks a slot. Offered times use this job's human booking notice, or Company → Human interview booking when inherited. It accepts 0–168 whole hours; 0 offers the next free slot within your availability. The account booking window normally ends 14 days ahead.

Slots come from your weekly availability and existing HireMike interviews. Busy events on a connected external calendar are not yet consulted — choose weekly hours you can reliably offer.

Until they book, their profile shows a Booking invitation sent panel: "A scheduling link was emailed to the candidate. Waiting for them to choose a time." It carries the date the link went out. After 48 hours it adds a "consider following up" prompt, and HireMike emails the candidate its own reminder. The link expires after 7 days, and you get "{candidate}'s booking link has expired — {job title}". When they book, you get an email with a calendar invite, and the candidate gets a confirmation with theirs.

Don't want to wait? Book on behalf of candidate in the same panel shows the free times, a week at a time, in your time zone. Pick one and HireMike books it and emails the candidate a confirmation. The button is there for an AI interview the candidate never booked as well.

"I'll set a time"

You already agreed a time by phone or email, or you want to pick one yourself. HireMike opens on a grid of your own free times — your weekly hours minus interviews you already have booked. Choose a slot and click Use this time. To type a time HireMike cannot check, use Enter a specific time instead; it then warns the time may clash or fall outside your working hours. If you have never set weekly hours, the modal starts on the typed field instead. Set the duration, format, location (for in-person) and an optional internal note ("Only visible to you"). The candidate gets a confirmation email with the details.

Managing a booked interview

Booked interviews appear in the Follow-up interviews panel on the profile, each with:

  • Mark completed — moves the candidate to Interviewed. Capture your verdict in the candidate's private notes (or the booking's internal note).
  • No-show — records that they didn't turn up. (Candidates are never auto-rejected for missing an interview you booked — this button is how you record it.)
  • Edit — adjust time/details (manually-set bookings only).
  • Cancel — with the option to "Send cancellation email to candidate".

Booked candidates sit in the Interview column; both scheduled reminders (24h/1h) go out automatically for their booking.

Note: Multiple rounds are fine — book again from Interviewed for a second conversation. Every booking is tracked in the same panel.

Rejecting

Reject opens a dialog with two decisions:

  1. Rejection email timing — dropdown:
    • Send immediately
    • Send in 48 hours
    • Send in 7 days
  2. Internal note (optional) — this field is not emailed or retained. Use the candidate’s Private notes for anything you’d like your team to refer to later.

Why delay? Two common reasons: you want to finish interviewing others before closing doors, or you'd rather rejections not land within minutes of the interview. Until the email sends, the candidate's status page keeps showing "Still in consideration", and you can change your mind.

Rejection cancels their live bookings and reminders at once, even when you delay the email.

The email itself is the CV rejection / Application update template (customisable).

The Rejected view

Click the funnel strip's Rejected button to see everyone who is out. Each carries the reason it ended:

Reason Set by
Knockout Failed the yes/no questions (automatic)
CV screening Failed AI screening (automatic, with 2-hour review window)
No-show Missed two booked AI interviews (automatic — interviews you book use the manual No-show button)
Employer You clicked Reject
Position filled Bulk-rejected when you completed a hire
Invitation expired A legacy on-demand AI interview link expired unused (automatic). An expired scheduled booking invitation does not reject the candidate
Review expired Nobody reviewed the candidate before the job's review deadline, so HireMike sent a rejection (automatic). Never attributed to you or to a colleague
Unsubscribed The candidate stopped all emails, which withdraws their live applications (automatic)

A rejection recorded before HireMike stored reasons shows as Employer decision or AI screening. The candidate's History tab always shows the true cause.

Rows whose rejection email hasn't gone out yet show "Rejection email pending" with a Cancel link. This covers both the automatic screening window and your own delayed rejections.

Cancelling stops the rejection email and restores the previous board stage where one existed:

  • Future bookings return only if their time has not passed and capacity remains available. Check History; arrange a new time if restoration failed.
  • A candidate rejected before reaching the board returns to AI Interview Requested on an AI job. Use Resend invitation to invite them.
  • On a human-led job, a candidate who had no earlier board stage returns to New.

Re-inviting a rejected candidate

Changed your mind after the email went out? Each rejected row has a Re-invite button:

  • On an AI job, they receive a fresh interview invitation (new link).
  • On a human-led job, they receive the shortlisted email and return to your board.

Note: On an AI job a re-invite starts a new interview, so it needs credit. At $0 the row shows "Your account has been suspended — top up to restore access." with a Top up link. A re-invite on a human-led job is only a board move, so it keeps working. See Billing.

Limit: a candidate can start at most three AI interviews for the same job. Past that, Re-invite is refused with "This candidate has already had 3 AI interviews for this job, which is the limit." Contact support if you need another attempt. Asking them to apply again with the same email address does not work: HireMike blocks duplicate applications for the same job. Resending an unused link does not count; only interviews the candidate actually started do.

Deleting an application

At the bottom of the profile, click Delete application… and type the candidate's exact name. Then click Permanently delete. Review this carefully before confirming: it permanently removes the application, CV, screening results, assessment, transcript, recording and bookings.

You cannot undo this action. Other applications from the same candidate remain, and HireMike retains financial records. For a normal hiring decision, use Reject.

Two candidates, one decision — comparing

Click Compare in the candidates toolbar for a side-by-side view of 2–4 candidates. It opens pre-loaded with your top two by score; swap any column with its dropdown, or + Add a third and fourth.

Rows cover the decision evidence, aligned so like compares with like:

  • Scores — CV score (with pass/fail), AI interview score, and your own 1–5 rating, editable right there. The highest score in each row gets a small accent dot.
  • CV criteria — one row per scoring criterion of this job, so every candidate is measured against the same yardstick; hover a bar for the AI's rationale.
  • Interview criteria & flags — the assessment breakdown plus any concerns/inconsistencies the AI raised.
  • Background — latest role, skills, and applied date from the parsed CV.

The selection lives in the URL, so you can share a comparison link with a teammate. When information is not available yet, such as an interview score before the interview, you’ll see "—" so it is easy to distinguish from a scored result. Prefer a spreadsheet? Export CSV on the candidates page downloads the whole pipeline.


Related: Reviewing candidates · Offers & hiring · Calendar & availability · Interview scheduling