Reviewing candidates
Bring the evidence together and decide who you’d like to get to know better. Your candidate board and profiles put CVs, interview results and team notes within easy reach. For the next steps, see Managing candidates and Offers & hiring.
The pipeline board
Open a job and you land on its Candidates tab (jobs with applications open here by default), showing Human Review, where you can focus on candidates ready for your next step. Every other state, including everyone still in the automated part of the funnel, is one click away on the funnel strip below the controls — one button per state, described below.
The AI Pipeline view
Click the strip's AI Pipeline button for candidates in the automated interview flow — invited, booked, or finishing up, while HireMike takes care of their next steps. They appear as the same candidate cards used everywhere else, so their badges tell you where each one is: AI Interview Requested (they hold an interview link but have picked no time) or AI Interview Scheduled with the date and time. When the interview is over and the assessment is written — or immediately after screening on human-led jobs — the candidate moves to Human Review.
A second row of filters above the list splits it further — All, AI Interview Requested and AI Interview Scheduled — each with its own count. The filters cover only the people who wait on an interview. A candidate whose assessment is still being written raises the AI Pipeline count, but the list below leaves them out. They reach Human Review as soon as the assessment is ready.
Candidates whose CVs are still being read are counted separately, under CV Processing, which has the same filters: All, CV Processing Queued and CV Unreadable. That list includes anyone whose CV couldn't be read, who shows as needing attention (a "CV could not be processed" panel on their profile) until they re-upload a readable file — see CV screening.
The board
A kanban board with six fixed columns:
New → Reviewed → Interview → Interviewed → Offer Sent → Hired
- New — fresh arrivals awaiting your review: AI-interviewed candidates with their assessment ready, or (human-led jobs) candidates fresh from CV screening. The funnel strip's CV Processing and AI Pipeline counts tell you how many more are still in the automated stages.
- Reviewed — you've looked and want them in the running.
- Interview — an interview you're running is booked.
- Interviewed — that interview is done.
- Offer Sent — an offer is out, awaiting response.
- Hired — done.
Use the action buttons on a candidate’s profile to move them forward. Each action makes the next step clear, including any email or booking that goes with it.
Cards
Each card shows the candidate's initials, name, email, and their scores on the right: CV for the CV score and AI for the interview score, each coloured green (70+), amber (50–69), or red (below 50). Once you rate someone, your stars sit under the scores. Cards also badge where the candidate is and anything that needs attention:
- CV Processing — the CV is queued or being read.
- CV Unreadable — we couldn't read the file, and the candidate has been asked for another.
- Can’t reach — HireMike cannot email this address. Open History to correct a bounced address.
- AI Interview Requested — invited, but they have picked no time yet.
- AI Interview Scheduled — a time is booked.
- ★ Shortlisted — your bookmark. (Not to be confused with the "You've been shortlisted" email human-led candidates receive on passing screening — the ★ is purely internal and sends nothing.)
- Finalising assessment… — the AI interview is done and we're preparing the assessment. This usually clears in seconds; the card then shows the interview score. If it lingers, we're finishing up in the background — nothing is needed from you, and you're only ever billed once the assessment is ready.
- Upcoming booking date/time and format.
- Offer accepted / Offer declined.
Finding people
The controls bar has:
- Search by name or email.
- Sort: Best score (default), Newest first, Oldest first, Name A–Z.
- Compare — put two candidates side by side, once a job has two. See Managing candidates.
- Export CSV — the whole pipeline as a spreadsheet, in Best score order (the default sort), whatever sort or filter you have on screen. The download stops at 5,000 candidates; a job larger than that exports its top 5,000 by the default sort.
Your rating and shortlist are internal review aids; they do not change the AI score or notify the candidate. Changing the job's scoring criteria does not recalculate earlier results, so check the written breakdown when comparing applicants screened at different times.
Rejected candidates are reached from the funnel strip's Rejected button rather than a separate view switch. They show their rejection reason (Knockout / CV screening / No-show / Employer / Position filled — automatic rejections for expired invitations or candidate withdrawals appear here too), score, and date. Pending (not yet emailed) rejections can be cancelled there; anyone can be re-invited. See Managing candidates.
The funnel strip
Under the controls, a strip shows where everyone is now — one button per state, always all seven, even at zero. Each button is also the way into that state's view: click one and the page below switches to the interface those candidates live in, with the button you picked outlined. Human Review is outlined when you arrive, since that's where a job opens.
| Button | Who it counts | What it opens |
|---|---|---|
| {n} Applied | Everyone who has ever applied — the total, not a state. | A list of every candidate. |
| {n} CV Processing | CVs being read now, plus deferred ones and CVs we couldn't read. | A list of candidate cards. |
| {n} Awaiting your review | Waiting on you. On AI interview jobs, three settings put people here: a review hold, a review deadline, or reading every CV yourself. Most jobs have none of them and this count stays at zero. | A list, soonest first, with Send now and Reject on each row and how long is left. Under a hold that reads Sends in about N days; under a deadline it reads Rejects in N days — the same wait, opposite endings. Tick several rows to invite or reject them together. |
| {n} AI Pipeline | In the automated interview flow: invited, booked, or finalising. | A list of candidate cards. |
| {n} Human Review | On your board before an offer — New through Interviewed. | The board, without the offer columns. |
| {n} Offered | At Offer Sent or Hired. | A list of candidate cards. |
| {n} Rejected | Everyone who is out, whatever ended it — knockout, CV screen, no-show, your decision, an expired invitation or an unsubscribe. | The Rejected view. |
The six states after Applied add up to Applied. They are current states, not cumulative totals, so every candidate is counted under exactly one of them — 22 + 0 + 66 + 49 + 3 + 260 = 400. Applied sits on its own before the divider because it is the total those six sum to, not a seventh state to add in.
Re-invite a rejected candidate and they leave Rejected for whichever state they land in.
Filtering from the dashboard
The Dashboard charts link into this same filter. With one job picked in the dashboard's job selector, click a figure and you land here. The matching candidates are already selected, on the right view — a rejection figure opens the Rejected view, not the board. On All Active Jobs a figure covers every job at once, so it opens a short list of jobs instead; pick one from it to come here. A figure counting zero does nothing. The filter it applied is shown as an extra button on the strip with an × to clear it. This is also how you reach rejection reasons the strip doesn't summarise.
The filter is in the page address, so a filtered list can be bookmarked or pasted to a colleague and it opens the same way.
Empty?
A freshly published job shows "Your job is live — waiting for the first application" with your application link ready to copy — sharing the link is the fix. You'll get an email when the first applicant lands.
The candidate profile
Click any card. The profile header shows the name, current stage badge, and the action bar (covered in Managing candidates). Your rating sits beside the actions and stays available across profile tabs. Contact details appear on Overview.
The Overview tab shows score cards beneath Candidate details:
- CV Score — with pass/fail colouring.
- Interview Score — the AI's score, or Finalising… while the assessment is still being written. Your rating is your own 1–5 stars (see Rating interviews yourself).
Booking state is a panel, not a tile. While you wait for an AI interview the profile shows Waiting for candidate to complete AI interview, with Resend invitation. While you wait for a candidate to pick a time for an interview you booked, it shows Booking invitation sent, with Book on behalf of candidate.
If the AI interviewer warned the candidate about their conduct, the Interview Score tile shows the warnings of each type — for example "3 warnings for abusive language, 1 warning for unconstructive replies." If the AI stopped the interview after three manipulation attempts, or a fourth incident of abusive or unconstructive conduct, the tile also shows a red Stopped — conduct policy badge. The stop is not a rejection: the candidate is on your board like any other, and the decision is yours. See Candidate conduct.
If the candidate got through fewer than half your questions, the Interview Score tile says so: "Interview ended early — only 2 of 5 questions answered. Score reflects a partial interview." The interview still finished, so it is scored, it reaches your board, and you are billed for it. Read the transcript before you trust the number.
Use Previous and Next below the tabs to move through the candidate list. The next profile keeps your current tab where that tab is available.
Tabs only appear once they have content. The open tab is part of the page's web address, so you can send a teammate a link that opens on the CV, and your browser's Back button returns to the tab you had open before. A link to a tab this candidate does not have opens on Overview.
Overview tab
The decision page:
- Candidate details — name, clickable email and phone, with copy buttons, and the date they applied. Phone shows Not provided when absent. Hover over the applied date to see the time.
- Offer status — while an offer is out: awaiting response or accepted, with dates, and whether the candidate responded via their link. Declining or withdrawing clears the row, and you can find the record on the Offer tab. Once you hire them, a Status row reads Hired.
- Interview Summary — the AI's written summary of the interview.
- Flags — three panels: Strengths (green), Concerns (red), Inconsistencies (amber).
- Private notes — a threaded note log: each entry shows who wrote it and when, and can be deleted. Visible to your whole team, never to candidates.
Cover letter tab
Only on an application that arrived by email: the cover letter that came with the forwarded CV. See How candidates apply.
Screening Qs tab
Every knockout question with the candidate's answer and a ✓/✗ against your required answer, plus the overall passed/failed footer.
CV tab
When AI screening is on, the tab starts with the result: score, pass/fail, rationale, criteria breakdown and Extracted CV Data. The original CV follows at the bottom, with one download button. PDFs open in the page; other formats offer a download. When screening is off, use the document and your rating to review the candidate. See CV screening.
If the AI couldn't score one of your criteria, a warning sits above the rationale — "⚠ 1 of 5 criteria was not scored" — and names it. An unscored criterion counts as zero at full weight, so consider the explanation alongside the score when deciding what to do next.
Interview tab
If the AI stopped the interview under the conduct policy, a panel at the top says why — for example "The AI interviewer stopped the interview at the fourth incident of abusive language." Watch the recording before you decide.
If the candidate's connection dropped, a panel at the top says how many times the interview was interrupted and how many times it resumed. The breaks are marked in the transcript, and the interviewer's spoken resume notice is in the recording — so you can hear what the candidate came back to.
The Interview tab starts with the same interview score card as Overview, followed by Criteria Breakdown, Summary, the video recording when available, the transcript, and Recording consent. Click any transcript line and the video jumps to that moment; the current line highlights as the video plays. The recording-consent record (status, timestamp, policy version) sits at the bottom.
Use Picture in picture in the video’s bottom control bar to open a floating player in supported browsers. The playback speed button shows the current speed and lets you choose playback from 0.5× to 2×. The player menu does not offer a download button.
New recordings with reliable timing also have Chapters & events below the video and markers above the seek bar. Main questions become chapters; follow-ups, repeats, connection drops, rejoins, audio-recovery pauses and completion have their own markers. Select a marker or list entry to seek and open its details. Question details show the words that were spoken; an interrupted question is labelled Partly spoken before interruption. Hover over or focus a marker for its label. On a touch screen, tap it. A numbered marker opens a chooser for the events close together at that point.
During a connection gap, the video shows Candidate disconnected. Skip to rejoin appears only when a matching return was recorded. When there is no recorded return, the player says so. Audio-recovery pauses have a separate message and remain visible until working audio is confirmed. These messages follow the video's current position, including after seeking backward. The original recording keeps the waiting periods. These review aids do not change question progress, assessment scores or billing.
Fullscreen keeps the markers and details with the video in browsers that support it. On browsers such as iPhone Safari that cannot expand the whole player into fullscreen, Expanded view keeps the video, controls and markers together. Picture in picture displays the video alone.
Older recordings, and recordings whose timing cannot be verified, play normally without chapters or event markers. Missing markers do not mean an interview had no interruptions.
Select a transcript line to seek without changing whether the video is playing or paused. The Follow playback switch starts on and keeps the active transcript line in view. Turn it off to browse freely. Seeking and scrolling do not change the switch. It stays off until you turn it on again. Reloading the page or navigating to another candidate restores the default.
The transcript opens in a tall, scrollable panel. Drag the grip in its bottom-right corner to resize it, or focus the grip and use the arrow keys. Returning from another browser tab keeps your playback position and transcript size. Switching to another candidate-profile tab pauses the video; returning to Interview keeps your position, transcript size and playback settings.
Older recordings may have saved timestamps from when an answer was stored rather than when it was spoken. These recordings remain playable, but transcript jumps and highlights may not match the audio exactly.
If the recording isn't available you'll see the transcript alone.
In new recordings, a Camera off placeholder means the candidate's camera was off or unavailable at that point. The conversation's audio continues, and video returns when their camera is back on. Older recordings are unchanged.
The full transcript is part of Interview, with each turn labelled by speaker and interruptions marked. Older links to the separate Transcript tab open Interview.
Offer tab
Appears once you send an offer, and stays after the hire: the terms as you sent them, the response, and how long the candidate has left. See Offers & hiring.
History tab
Follow the application’s story in one place. History lists activity with the newest entry first, showing what happened, who was involved and when.
That includes the automatic steps as well as yours — the CV check and its score, the interview invitation, the candidate confirming their email address, picking (or changing, or cancelling) an interview time, turning up to the AI interview, each conduct warning the AI gave, the report, what it cost you, every offer and its answer, and every note added or deleted.
Emails sit underneath the thing that caused them, in smaller text — "HireMike sent the offer email to the candidate" hangs under "Sam sent an offer to the candidate", along with anything HireMike did to repair the application behind the scenes. A failed send appears the same way, so you can always see whether a candidate was actually reached.
A bounced email offers Fix address. Enter the correct email address, then click Save and send again. HireMike updates the address and resends the email.
Rating interviews yourself
A 1–5 star rating sits at the top beside the candidate actions and stays available across profile tabs. It is your own take on the candidate, including before AI screening or an interview. Ratings also appear in the Compare view and are private to your team.
Where's the follow-up interview stuff?
At the top of Overview, above Candidate details, a Follow-up interviews panel appears once you book interviews of your own — each with date, duration, format, and actions. That's part of Managing candidates.
Related: Managing candidates · Offers & hiring · CV screening · The AI interview